All 6 Marvel Phase Five Movies, Ranked

Add Looper on Google:
Google Discover

Phase Five of the Marvel Cinematic Universe was easily the most tormented and bizarre stretch of this franchise's history. Even the ups and downs of Phase Four could at least ride some post-"Avengers: Endgame" goodwill, the record-shattering box office of "Spider-Man: No Way Home," and four consecutive movies that cleared $340+ million domestically each. The critical reception wasn't as consistently strong as past phases, but the MCU still had a firm grip on pop culture in Phase Four. In contrast, Phase Five was full of long-term plans collapsing (namely anything related to Kang the Conqueror), actual box office bombs, and Marvel Studios persistently overhauling its general output plans.

The confidence that had informed Marvel Studios eras, where this label dared to put out movies based on Iron Man and Guardians of the Galaxy, seemed to elude the company during an immensely precarious Phase Five. Now that this phase is finished and "Avengers: Doomsday" is almost here, the six movies comprising Phase Five are a fascinating collection of motion pictures. Ranking these six movies from worst to best (based on the personal opinions of this author) makes clear the creative hurdles and artistic shortcomings that plagued so many MCU movies in this era.

The best Phase Five movies, unfortunately, only render the faults of weaker Phase Five features more unavoidable. "Welcome to the MCU, by the way. You're joining at a bit of a low point," Deadpool observes in the Phase Five movie "Deadpool & Wolverine," which succinctly sums up this era's six motion pictures.

6. Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania

What happened here? How did "Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania" go so far astray that it is basically the superhero movie equivalent of 1967's "Doctor Dolittle," a costly boondoggle that capsizes all audience interest in a once mighty genre? Director Peyton Reed and company opting to realize the Quantum Realm as such a dimly lit, drab, and CG-heavy locale was a fatal flaw. The whole movie looks ugly and isn't a remotely pleasant domicile to place your eyeballs for two hours. Then there are the befuddling storytelling decisions related to making "Quantumania" a massive spectacle-driven movie rather than another of the low-key fun comedies of previous "Ant-Man" installments.

Gone are the fun gags or intersections of divorced parenting life with superhero antics. In their place is a lot of teasing for eventually abandoned Kang the Conqueror plans and repellent digital effects work. Also, there is just no humanity to this hollow movie. Evangeline Lilly's Hope van Dyne/The Wasp is a non-entity, while Kathryn Newton's Cassie Lang is similarly given little to do. Venturing into another dimension means nothing if there aren't compelling characters to anchor the voyage. "Quantumania" couldn't even deliver fun or compelling action, something past Marvel movies did with aplomb.

While earlier "Ant-Man" movies are light on their feet and fun, "Quantumania" is an often murky-looking chore. Reed and screenwriter Jeff Loveness fumbled the ball mightily in this project that had scale aplenty, but no wit or soul to speak of.

5. Captain America: Brave New World

Speaking of stupefying Marvel Cinematic Universe movies, "Captain America: Brave New World" is plagued by several creative miscalculations that sink the whole production. For starters, why on Earth is so much of this motion picture, ostensibly focused on Sam Wilson's Captain America, centered around following up on lore from "The Incredible Hulk"? Given that Wilson has no emotional connection to that movie and how long it'd been between "Hulk" and "Brave New World," suddenly expecting audiences to care about Samuel Sterns/The Leader (Tim Blake Nelson) and President Ross (Harrison Ford) again is maddening. That alone ensures this movie doesn't fully work.

Further problems, though, emerge in creative impulses like the dearth of memorable new foes for Wilson's Captain America to face. A tediously "grounded" vision of the Serpent Society just doesn't cut it. Insultingly obvious green-screen work scattered throughout the runtime also proves distracting. Worst of all, though, is that Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson has nothing to do in this movie. Since all of the complicated character material goes to Ross, Wilson is a spectator for too much of "Brave New World."

Any of the memorable hand-to-hand fight scenes populating "Captain America: The Winter Soldier," meanwhile, are absent here. They're traded out for choppily edited set pieces lacking gripping fight choreography. With no excitement or transfixing character-based drama to work with, audiences are left adrift while watching "Brave New World," which was doomed from its earliest core storytelling decisions.

4. Deadpool & Wolverine

In 2008, Marvel Studios took a massive risk in making a live-action movie based on Iron Man. Four years later, the idea of teaming up various superheroes for one mega-blockbuster was similarly untested waters. 2024's "Deadpool & Wolverine," on the other hand, is one of the most frustratingly safe movies in a Disney-owned franchise known for giving the people what they want. This team-up between Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman is all about reveling in the past, as seen in every "Deadpool & Wolverine" cameo or even every variant of Logan seen in one montage sequence. If you want fan service, "Deadpool & Wolverine" has you covered.

That's not to say the film is devoid of charm. Jackman proves as solid as ever in the role of Wolverine, while Emma Corrin makes for a fun baddie. Most of "Deadpool & Wolverine," though, lacks pomp and circumstance. Director Shawn Levy largely leaves any visual flair behind, opting for stale blocking and a very limited definition of what "colorful" cinema looks like. Despite the bright yellow and red costumes worn by the titular leads, too much of "Deadpool & Wolverine" is still set in gray landscapes and unimaginatively lit interiors. The story doesn't go anywhere especially unpredictable, while the vulgar jokes blur together quite quickly.

"Deadpool & Wolverine" isn't incompetently made, but there is a cynical obsession with the past to produce easy crowd-pleaser moments that leaves a bad taste in one's mouth. Here's hoping Levy steps up his game for his next MCU gig, "Ghost Rider."

3. The Marvels

"The Marvels" is a cautionary tale on many fronts. For one thing, it's the movie that reflected the dangers of propping up the MCU theatrical films so heavily on the TV side of the franchise. Plus, "The Marvels" bombing at the box office was the worst-case outcome for Marvel Studios that any future MCU title would love to avoid. Most importantly, though, this was a reflection of what happens when Marvel Studios doesn't trust the directors it hires. Filmmaker Nia DaCosta has an outstanding track record with titles like "28 Years Later: The Bone Temple," "Hedda," and "Little Woods," the last of which is one of the best Western movies with a female lead.

DaCosta has openly talked about how her initial creative vision for "The Marvels" never made it to the big screen, making it no wonder that the film is more jagged and less satisfying than her other filmmaking exploits. Despite this, "The Marvels" does have its share of virtues, including a great scene where a bunch of space cats gobble people up as a vintage show tune plays, while Iman Vellani as Kamala Khan/Ms. Marvel is persistently delightful. Some of the costumes look solid, and the three leads have generally good chemistry.

Unfortunately, those better elements exist next to one of the worst baddies the MCU has ever produced and a finale that gets so big in scope it's impossible to take it seriously. It's not an all-time disaster, but "The Marvels" is still a frustratingly flawed exercise.

2. Thunderbolts*

If "Thunderbolts*" had a livelier visual scheme, there's a chance it could be a top-tier MCU movie. Unfortunately, this feature's got too much cramped framing for its own good, ditto excessive amounts of light blue color grading and a dearth of bright hues. More vibrancy and specificity in the sets and camerawork would've really bolstered a motion picture that does a lot of things right. This title uniting anti-heroes like Yelena Belova (Florence Pugh) and Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan) is a more intimate exercise compared to "Brave New World" and "Quantumania," which lets the strong performances and endearingly flawed personalities shine.

To boot, compared to other Phase Five titles, "Thunderbolts*" doesn't feel like it was hastily cobbled together in the editing room. Instead, the story actually has a proper structure one can follow rather than a hodgepodge narrative bogged down by cameos. There's even a nicely realized climax relying on confronting past trauma and emotional solidarity rather than just a barrage of punching. Director Jake Schreier also proves adept at getting good performances out of his actors, including Lewis Pullman as MCU newbie Bob/The Sentry. It doesn't hurt, of course, that a performer as tremendous as Pugh is around to anchor everything.

She's excellent here and helps accentuate the messy humanity informing the surprisingly solid superhero movie that is "Thunderbolts*." Now if only they'd remembered to turn on some more lights and embrace a brighter color palette...

1. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3

The very existence and subsequent success of "Guardians of the Galaxy" defied all conventional wisdom. How on Earth did writer/director James Gunn make these ragtag, obscure Marvel characters into household names? It's only fitting, then, that "Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3" would similarly subvert cinematic standards by providing the rare third superhero movie in a franchise that fully satisfies. This entry involves Rocket Raccoon (Bradley Cooper) confronting his past, and each member of the titular team ends up in a comforting, emotionally moving place. The ending of "Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3" provides firm finality to this trilogy and clear character growth for folks like Star-Lord, Mantis, and Drax.

"Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3" also sees Gunn feeling clearly more comfortable and bolder than ever in making a comic book movie. This entry is full of weirdo touches (like a planet of humanoid animals, some of which deal drugs) and dares to be unflinching in its depiction of the animal abuse Rocket endures at the hands of the High Evolutionary (Chukwudi Iwuji). These audacious elements aren't requisite additions in any modern superhero movie, but Gunn not only delivers the unexpected, but he also realizes those unique qualities with finesse. Thus, both the excitement and poignancy here are firing on all cylinders.

Everything must come to an end, and "Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3" provides such a phenomenal version of that inevitability while also delivering a level of cohesive storytelling and humanity evading most Phase Five MCU features.

Recommended