5 Most Realistic Submarine Movies Of All Time

We've already counted down our choices for the best and the most underrated submarine movies, but directors don't necessarily have to get the facts right to make a good flick. However, other films deserve credit for attempting to accurately translate the realities of life in the silent service to the screen, giving viewers the chance to experience what life really is like on board. The following five movies have been spoken highly by Navy veterans and have a special place in their hearts. Whether an intense wartime epic or a more general portrayal of routine submarine life, these films all stuck to the facts.

As we've never been stationed on a submarine ourselves, we've trawled the internet to find firsthand expert opinions of Navy personnel and military historians to narrow down this list. This meant discovering some lesser-known titles, while reassessing others that we would have assumed were deeply inaccurate before we learned otherwise. There will be some shocking snubs and even more surprising inclusions below, so don't hold your breath and expect your favorite movie in this genre to appear. However, if you've come here looking for recommendations that dive deeper into the heart of Navy service, you're in the right place.

All titles below are listed alphabetically, although the movie frequently cited as being most accurate just happens to be the first one we're going to talk about.

Author Lothar-Günther Buchheim was a war reporter for the Reich's propaganda regime during World War II, but it wasn't until three decades later that he wrote an explicitly anti-war account of his experience shadowing submarine crews in his bestseller "Das Boot." Director Wolfgang Petersen, bettr known for the terrifying '80s dark fantasy classic "The NeverEnding Story," enlisted various real-life crew members, including the captain of the real U-96 Heinrich Lehmann-Willenbrock, as consultants throughout production, ensuring a painstaking attention to technical detail.

"Das Boot" became the most expensive German movie ever made at that time, as Petersen used his team of naval advisers to verify every last detail of the submarine sets, working from archival photographs, former newsreel footage, and design blueprints to ensure maximum realism. Everything from the claustrophobic walkways to blink-and-you'll-miss-them valve placements are mirrored from real designs.

Now considered by many to be a legendary submarine movie, it's also frequently cited by Navy veterans as the most authentic depiction of submarine life ever depicted onscreen. Although tensions are ramped up in "Das Boot" due to the faltering vehicle and consistent wartime threats, it also faithfully captures the monotonous routine servicemen have faced outside of battle, as well as the everyday anxieties of extreme weather conditions.

It should be stressed that Buchheim himself was unsatisfied, feeling it overly dramatized the reality, where soldiers were more emotionally composed. We can forgive those moments of melodrama, as Petersen's movie is a masterclass in suffocating tension that few military thrillers have equaled.

Yes, you have read that correctly — the badly reviewed 1996 Kelsey Grammer comedy "Down Periscope" is one of the most authentic screen depictions of submarine life, with several Navy veterans citing it as the closest to their own experiences. Only 11% of Rotten Tomatoes critics appreciated it, but beneath the unfunny over-the-top comic hijinks, there's a realism to the lived-in dynamics of the crew, whose relationships are forged on low supplies, bad diets, and doing whatever it takes to stave off boredom.

Nobody was coming to "Down Periscope" expecting ultra realism, and it's in that regard the movie strays from the facts. But when it comes to the broader aspects of workplace comedy, many with firsthand experience have said it's well observed. On one Reddit thread, some veterans have even argued it's closer to a documentary than countless serious naval thrillers. The characters may all be heightened archetypes, but many experts have stressed this isn't too far from the truth. The nature of the job attracts a lot of socially awkward eccentrics, and the mundanity leaves you entertaining yourself in-between duties.

Multiple viewers also felt the portrayal of rivalry between high-ranking officers was particularly true to what they witnessed aboard. For all its high concept comedy, it understands what drives crew relationships better than most submarine movies.

"Hell Below" is the first of two romantic melodramas on this list, both centering on a love triangle where the two men fighting over a woman happen to be stationed at sea. And while this World War I drama was made in co-operation with the Navy, it does heighten the truth for the sake of classic Hollywood thrills. Lt. Comdr. Morris D. Gilmore, who patrolled the U.S. Atlantic coast during WWI, served as the technical consultant, informing the film's design — the movie's military realism was especially singled out for praise.

The film has largely fallen into obscurity, so there isn't too much contemporary writing from official sources about what it gets right and wrong, so take this extensive Reddit thread from user IlluminatiRex assessing the movie's accuracy with a pinch of salt. They highlight some errors including a newer S-Class model ship being used as a substitute for an older L-class vessel, as well as a plot depicting the crew in the Adratic and Mediterranean seas, two combat areas where U.S. submarines weren't deployed during WWI.

They believe more accuracy is shown in the most taxing aspect of daily operations, such as the physical strain of reloading torpedoes, one of the most dangerous duties required in combat. Ultimately, even if the filming location wasn't faithful to the time, the movie attempts make it look WWI specific, and the depiction of operations is accurate enough to still resonate with anybody who has served.

On the surface, this 1937 Lloyd Bacon-directed film is classic Old Hollywood fare; two sailors (Pat O'Brien and Wayne Morris) are best friends stationed together off the Panama coast, only fighting to get the attention of Ann Sawyer (Doris Weston). Beneath the sugary love triangle surface, you'll find a surprisingly realistic depiction of U.S. Navy operations prior to WWII, made with the full co-operation of the Navy. It was so painstakingly researched that the final movie had to be approved by the Navy to ensure it didn't unintentionally reveal military secrets.

This movie has largely been forgotten over time; there are no critic reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, and not enough Letterboxd user reviews to calculate an average rating. However, a small audience of submarine enthusiasts remain drawn to its depiction of procedural maneuvers and other operational duties members of the silent service were required to carry out. Letterboxd reviews all highlight that you'll need a keen interest in those factors, as the love story at its core feels perfunctory.

It makes for an intriguing period piece when contrasting modern operations and feels oddly prescient due to a climactic action set piece (where the crew must use escape lungs to get out of their sunken boat) that foreshadowed the loss of the USS Squalus in 1939. An intriguing curio, but one only for those with a deep appreciation for the specifics in how service has changed over the years.

The most recent title on this list is "The Wolf's Call," a 2019 French thriller which has been highly commended for its commitment to realism. Directed by Antonin Baudry — who was originally a diplomat and speechwriter to former French foreign minister Dominique de Villepin — the film imagines a high-stakes international incident that risks a war with Russia. Baudry spent a month onboard an active French military submarine to ensure this didn't draw from genre conventions, noting the differences in France's naval operations. This helps distinguish the movie's depiction from what you'd typically see in a Hollywood blockbuster.

With his previous profession in mind, "The Wolf's Call" excels at capturing the minutiae of the administrative details, both on board and on land; it understands the daily operations procedures of all personnel involved, invoking all the appropriate jargon. It sacrifices some of this realism as the story becomes a traditional action thriller, with certain set pieces defying physics, and the depiction of sonar is heavily fictionalized for drama.

It makes up for this with its portrayal of crew life, especially the highly stressful role of a sonar expert (François Civil). The threat he is tasked with determining may be heightened, but the dynamics drawn and the attention to detail in this portrayal of submarine operations makes it easy to forgive. It becomes a conventional Hollywood-style blockbuster, but it puts effort in establishing greater authenticity before then.