The Untold Truth Of DC's Starman

Starman has been part of the DC universe since his debut in 1941. Unlike many DC heroes who have had just one or two incarnations, however, 11 different men have shouldered the Starman mantle at one point or another. And that doesn't even include Stargirl, a character who acts as a reinvention of and successor to the Starman legacy.

Where does one begin with Starman? Well, you have a few options. There's Ted Knight, the original Starman, and his son Jack Knight, likely the two most well-known Starmen. Ted was created by writer Gardner Fox and artist Jack Burnley, while Jack Knight was created by James Robinson and Tony Harris in a 1994 revival of the title. During the latter comic's Eisner Award-winning run, Jack and Ted are connected to the many other Starmen out there — and to some heroes who simply have the word "star" in their name. There are alien Starmen inspired by David Bowie, time-traveling Starmen, Starmen who stand to inherit extraterrestrial thrones, and even a dead Starman, who can nevertheless talk to the living. 

Sound confusing? It is — but it's all held together by the Starman mantle's legacy of family, generational inheritance, and heroism. We're here to break down the Starman story, from the 1940s' tales of super science to the 1990s' reinvention of the character and his history.

One of the most enigmatic figures of the '90s Starman series is the Starman of 1951, who took on the role for just one year. This Starman is, in fact, a retconned version of Batman, glimpsed in 1957's Detective Comics #247. In this issue, an evil scientist manages to give Batman a phobia of bats — so Bruce Wayne replaces his signature bats with stars. Instead of a Bat-Signal, he has a Star-Signal. Instead of Batarangs, he uses Star-Darts. In the end, Robin uses exposure therapy to cure Bruce, who goes back to being a creature of the night.

The '90s Starman series makes Charles McNider, the first Doctor Mid-Nite, into Starman instead of Batman. At the time, Ted Knight is incapacitated and is in and out of sanitariums after his nervous breakdown. McNider sees the need for Opal City to have a champion, and he takes over until a replacement is found. This replacement turns out to be a time-traveling David Knight, son of Ted Knight and older brother to Jack Knight. He takes over for his dad, but David lasts less than a week before he is murdered by Kyle, the son of Ted's arch-enemy, the Mist. He is eventually given a second chance to be Starman, this time in the past. David makes the most of it and is even able to team up with Jack before he has to meet his fate in his own era.

Introduced in 1980's Adventure Comics #467, Prince Gavyn of Throneworld has nothing to do with any of the Starmen of Earth ... or so he thinks. As a bored, spoiled playboy, he's a classic comics archetype — he has no interest in ruling Throneworld and is happy to let his sister do it. The only problem is that it is customary to throw potential threats to the throne out of an airlock in case they decide to get ambitious. Thus, Gavyn is tossed into space. But he doesn't die, thanks to his hitherto unknown cosmic powers. Wielding a staff not unlike Jack Knight's Cosmic Rod, he dons a mask and becomes the protector of Throneworld's downtrodden. When his sister is murdered, he ascends the throne and is beloved by all. 

He apparently dies during Crisis On Infinite Earths ... except he doesn't. A new Starman series debuted in 1988, featuring an Earth man named Will Payton in the title role. He has the usual array of powers: flight, strength, and energy beams. He's disintegrated fighting Eclipso ... except he isn't. Turns out, Gavyn is the one who zapped Will with powers in the first place. He turned into pure energy upon his first "death," beaming across the universe until he found Will. His essence is thus merged with Payton's, and that energy beams back to Throneworld after Eclipso's attack. Eventually, Jack frees him, and Gavyn retains both his and Will's memories. He decides to stay on Throneworld.

Once a year, the '90s Starman series featured a "Talking With David" issue, in which Jack talks with his deceased brother David. Because of a pirate's curse on Opal City, David's spirit didn't move on when he died, and thanks to a favor from Dr. Fate, David is able to interact with Jack. These meetings heal a lifetime's worth of enmity.

The first such story came in Starman #5, when Jack Knight suddenly appears in black and white and sees his dead brother David dressed in the red and gold Starman suit. They meet in a cemetery and begin working out their mutual contempt and bitterness. David, ever his father's son, rarely sees eye-to-eye with Jack. Their second meeting puts them on a big pirate ship adventure. Their third time together happens at a dinner party with a large group of dead Golden Age heroes, who all have advice for Jack. David also visits Mikaal Tomas twice after that, offering him advice and encouragement.

David's last visit with Jack comes after Ted dies saving Opal City, meaning Jack gets to visit with both of them. They send Jack back to 1951, where he teams up with fellow time-traveler David, and encourages Ted to take up the Starman mantle once again.

During the DC One Million event, the Starman of the 853rd century, Farris Knight, plays a prominent role. The Justice Legion of the future comes back to the 20th century in order to retrieve the current-day JLA, so they can celebrate the return of the Prime Superman. However, there is a traitor on the team: Farris Knight. He's a direct descendant of Ted Knight, but also a direct descendant of Starman's nemesis, the Mist. His mission in the 20th century is to kill Ted Knight and plant Kryptonite on Mars for Solaris, a corrupted sun and Superman villain, in the future.

Farris reveals that after 3000 years without a Starman, his great-grandfather found a device called a Quarvat and used it to fight evil. His son, Cale Knight, took the Quarvat when the time came and became one of the greatest Starmen ever. His mother also took up the mantle, and explored Knight family history. Farris, in contrast, has never wanted to be a hero. He travels back in time to kill Ted — but Ted accepts him with kindness, and simply asks Farris to look inside himself and see if there is good there, too. Farris ends up sacrificing his life to save Earth from Solaris, with his great-grandfather finding the Quarvat millennia later.

The Starman legacy is all about generational inheritance. Ted Knight looms large in the life of his sons as a hero. The Mist warps his children with hatred, to use them as instruments against Ted Knight. Jack Knight quits being Starman so he can raise his own children in a safe environment. Every person who holds the title across time and space feels a kinship to each other, and not just because many of them wield the same kind of cosmic energy.

This legacy continues with Stargirl, now making waves in her own CW TV show. Courtney Whitmore debuted in the pages of Stars and S.T.R.I.P.E., where she discovers that her stepfather Pat Dugan was once Stripesy, the sidekick of Sylvester Pemberton, the Star-Spangled Kid. Pemberton wore a Cosmic Converter Belt, which enhanced his strength and speed. Whitmore uses the belt to become a superhero in her own right.

On the TV show, Dugan was still Pemberton's sidekick, but here he was Starman, wielding the Cosmic Staff. Courtney takes up his mantle in part because she believes Starman was her real father and wants to capture his killers, the Injustice Society. These legacies form the crux of the first season, along with the father-daughter dynamic of Pat and Courtney. What parents give to and demand of their children, and how those children react, is a powerful storytelling device, and the foundation of the Starman story.