5 Best Western Romance Movies Of All Time, Ranked
The best Western movies are often associated with gunfights and the trials of frontier life, but that doesn't mean they lack heartwarming moments. In fact, some of the greatest horse operas boast romances that tug at the old heartstrings — and those are the flicks we are celebrating today.
That's not to say romantic Westerns lack violence and horror, mind you. In fact, some of the movies we've picked are renowned for their intense action set-pieces and chaotic shootouts. So, if you prefer Westerns about rugged gunslingers shooting down bad guys, fear not, we have you covered.
That said, others are more family-friendly affairs that are all about the healing power of the American West and the romances that brew there. Meanwhile, some are about doomed romances set in societies poisoned by prejudice. With that said, here are five great Western romance movies that you should add to your watchlist.
5. The Man from Snowy River (1982)
Our first pick comes from Australia, and it's an old-fashioned Western featuring genre veteran Kirk Douglas in a dual role. "The Man from Snowy River" is also one of the best coming-of-age movies about frontier life, telling the story of a young man forced to grow up sooner than anticipated.
Based on Banjo Paterson's poem of the same name, "The Man from Snowy River" follows Jim (Tom Burlinson) as he overcomes grief and falls in love. After losing his father, the young man accepts a job on a ranch owned by Harrison (Kirk Douglas), where he develops a romance with his daughter, Jessica (Sigrid Thornton).
"The Man from Snowy River" is relatively non-violent. However, the film boasts a thrilling sense of adventure, as Jim navigates the wild frontier to prove his worth to the other cowboys and get Jessica's stubborn father to approve of their love. There's nothing particularly original about the story, but viewers who've had to deal with their lovers' disapproving parents will relate.
4. The Horse Whisperer (1998)
"The Horse Whisperer" is a great movie for animal lovers, but fans of romantic Westerns will also get a kick out of it. Here, Robert Redford plays a cowboy who specializes in healing horses back to health. When Annie (Kristin Scott Thomas) enlists his services, it doesn't take long for sparks to fly between them in Montana.
"The Horse Whisperer" is perfect viewing for fans of Taylor Sheridan's "The Madison," as both stories feature city slickers falling in love with Montana and the men who reside there. However, "The Horse Whisperer" might not sit well with viewers who expect a happy love story. It's a complex tale emphasizing the notion that love isn't always enough. Sure, people can form strong emotional connections, but other factors can stop them from being together.
Redford's film was seemingly designed to tug at the heartstrings, and that's okay. It might be too sentimental for some, but most will likely succumb to tears during the sappier moments.
3. Legends of the Fall (1994)
If you are looking for an epic Western with a complicated love story, "Legends of the Fall" is the movie for you. Edwin Zwick's drama is a sweeping tale of a family led by Colonel William Ludlow (Anthony Hopkins) dealing with war, love, and loss in Montana — and features Brad Pitt in an early role.
The love story also gets between the family, involving three brothers with feelings for the same woman. Susannah (Julia Ormond) is with Samuel (Henry Ludlow), but she has the hots for Tristan (Pitt). However, circumstances lead to her marrying Alfred (Aidan Quinn), adding to the melodrama.
Pitt wanted to quit "Legends of the Fall" after the table read, but made the right call to stick around. "Legends of the Fall" is an ambitious Western, drawing plaudits for its sense of grandeur and beautiful storytelling, so why wouldn't an actor want it on their resume? Like other films on this list, it doesn't give viewers the fairy tale romance they want to see, but some love stories are too messy for happy endings.
2. Brokeback Mountain (2005)
No list of great romantic Westerns would be complete without "Brokeback Mountain," Ang Lee's drama about two cowboys who fall in love during a summer in Wyoming. The film was nominated for eight Oscars and won three, with the story being praised for its emotional depiction of a gay relationship.
"Brokeback Mountain" centers on Ennis del Mar (Ledger) and Jack Twist (Gyllenhaal), who come together after being hired as sheep herders. They eventually return to their wives and families, but keep meeting up throughout the years to continue their romance. The story begins in the 1960s, when society was less receptive to men dating men, and the film isn't shy about depicting homophobia in a brutally honest light.
Lee's film came out at a time when pro-LGBTQ+ movies were rare from mainstream studios. However, it was a major blockbuster success, and many pundits argue that it was robbed of a best picture win after losing to the divisive "Crash." Awards aside, "Brokeback Mountain" is an excellent movie that deserves to be celebrated as one of the best Westerns of the 21st century.
1. Open Range (2003)
Kevin Costner's "Open Range" isn't a romantic movie in the traditional sense. The story follows a group of humble cattlemen who get into a dust-up with a ruthless baron and his goons, meaning that guns are drawn and bodies stack up quickly. "Open Range" is famous for one of the best gunfights in movie history, which doesn't exactly scream romance. But a love story blossoms between Costner's character Charley and Sue Barlow (Annette Bening), giving the film some heart.
The romance in "Open Range" is also notable for centering around mature characters. Charley is a gunslinger with a violent past — the type of guy who feels like an outsider even among company. Meanwhile, Sue is a middle-aged woman who's experienced a lifetime of disappointment and feels tainted. They know how it feels to be worn down, and that's what makes their love worth rooting for.
"Open Range" treats viewers to a slow-brewing love story that grows through quiet and intimate moments. It also adds more stakes to the violent showdown, as Charley and Sue have even more to lose if things don't pan out. He might have made "Dances with Wolves," but "Open Range" is Costner's real masterpiece.