The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping Review - An Underwhelming Return To Panem
- Another strong ensemble of newcomers and character actors, with few weak links
- An impressively downbeat third act
- Relies too heavily on fan service
- First in the franchise that feels like a retread of an earlier movie
- Tacked-on happy ending ruins the third act at the final minute
The Hunger Games wasn't responsible for Gen Z's political awakening, but a decade removed from the first wave of the movie adaptations, you can see how an action franchise touting the broad theme of resistance struck a longer-lasting chord than the many YA romances of its era. This is why I felt 2023's prequel "The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes" was one of the strongest in the series, sidelining the games themselves after the midway point to chart the fallout of a failed revolution: less a villain origin story in the mold of the Star War" prequels than it was this franchise's equivalent to "Andor."
It was boldly downbeat in how it charted a young Coriolanus Snow's (Tom Blyth) journey from rebel idealist to state-appointed fascist, more reflective of current divides in American society than any of the movies that preceded it. There was a renewed urgency that ensured it didn't register as a nostalgic cash grab — and in the wake of its box office underperformance, "The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" feels like returning director Francis Lawrence's attempt to retell that same story of a failed revolution with more crowd-pleasing zeal.
This prequel leans too much into fan service
It's the first time the Hunger Games franchise has succumbed to fan service, reintroducing younger versions of several noteworthy characters in the supporting cast (their futures all hinted at via awkward winking dialogue) in a narrative that's a less exciting retread of the "The Hunger Games: Catching Fire" Quarter Quell. If it weren't for the hands-on involvement of author Suzanne Collins, I'd assume this glorified greatest hits package was the result of endless studio notes, demanding the filmmakers repeat the formula of the most financially successful installment. But Francis Lawrence and returning screenwriters Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie have once again faithfully adapted her novel, which feels like a cash-grab exercise in itself; if the previous prequel spoke to the turbulent moment, this only speaks to what the creatives cynically assume fans want from a Hunger Games movie after the last one struggled to connect.
"The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" is by far the weakest entry in the franchise, but it does remain engaging as it regurgitates a tried-and-tested formula thanks to a mostly stellar ensemble of fresh faces and character actors. As the young Haymitch Abernathy, newcomer Joseph Zada mercifully avoids a Woody Harrelson impersonation, believably depicting how a young idealist — forced into the Games after a rebelling tribute is shot in front of him — would try to keep the spark of hope alive in a system that's openly telling him he's being set up to die. Alongside three other tributes from the impoverished District 12, including McKenna Grace's defiantly catty Maysilee Donner (the owner of the original Mockingjay pin), he arrives at the Capitol not hiding his desire for an uprising.
After a young tribute dies in an opening ceremony riot, Haymitch's angered reaction to President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) sees the gamemakers try to rig everything against him, but he has other plans. Working with previous victors who are now reluctant mentors — including Wiress (Maya Hawke) and Bettee Lattier (Kelvin Harrison Jr.), he's entrusted with acting as a lone wolf to sabotage the arena from the inside. He has a powerful ally in producer Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons, taking over from the late Philip Seymour Hoffman), but when everything is being recorded and the tyrannical president is keeping a close eye on him specifically, the odds aren't ever in his favor. Plemons — who starred alongside Hoffman in Paul Thomas Anderson's "The Master" — does the best job in the ensemble when it comes to avoiding mimicry of an earlier performance, cementing his status as a spiritual successor to Hoffman's A-list character actor throne.
It also undermines its own darkness
Next to Elle Fanning's Effie Trinket (which is enjoyable but too indebted to Elizabeth Banks' heavily mannered performance, and becomes obvious considering that Fanning bears the brunt of the clunky foreshadowing dialogue) and Kieran Culkin going too far in the opposite direction, insufferably wearing his "Succession" schtick into the ground as an iteration of host Caesar Flickerman too dissimilar to Stanley Tucci's to function, Jesse Plemons balances the tightrope of finding a unique perspective on a character without betraying his prior incarnation. More impressively, he makes it look easy.
Released a month after "Digger," Plemons' take on Plutarch feels in conversation with his role there as a shadowy billionaire heir, funding art that criticized his family's legacy so he could rehabilitate his own image. Here, he plays another person looming in the shadows of a sinister operation, appearing empathetic while also wielding tools to save his own skin and stop a rebellion if necessary; few actors have proven as strong at underplaying the moral slipperiness of such characters. A post-Games monologue to the broken Haymitch about how he was inspired by events that weren't allowed to be televised would feel at home in his big "Digger" monologue, where he cynically discussed the power of art in another dystopia where meaningful revolution was impossible.
Unlike "The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes," which rushed through the Games to focus on their aftermath, this latest prequel only devotes the final 20 minutes to Haymitch readjusting to civilian life with PTSD and crushed hopes of a revolution. This stretch does a great job twisting the knife, recontextualizing the earlier action so we see it how a viewer watching on TV in Panem would, and setting up a bleak finale that explains the character's descent into depression and addiction when we meet him decades later. The boldness doesn't quite compensate for the rest of the movie relying too heavily on familiar beats that made the franchise's inherent flaws visible for the first time — when there's little tension, the bloodlessness does become distracting — but is an admirably downbeat note to end on.
It's a shame there's a tacked-on, flash-forward happy ending that immediately undermines its effectiveness, which I assumed was the result of a studio note, only to discover this is how Suzanne Collins ended the book, too. For each moment of promise that hints at new ways this dystopian dictatorship quashes uprisings and keeps its citizens in line, "The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" counters with dozens more moments of awkward, self-indulgent fan service that detracts from the story's power. It's a greatest hits movie at a time when fans would be far more receptive to something as radical as its darkest narrative ideas, failing to meet the moment its predecessor did effortlessly.
"The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" lands in theaters on November 20.