Disney CEO Responds To Star Wars Outrage

When you're at the controls of a giant franchise, you can't please everybody — and this seems to go double for Star Wars fans.

Disney CEO Bob Iger took a philosophical approach to fans' dissatisfaction with the sequel trilogy during a conversation with Variety at the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker premiere. Iger acknowledged that, while the creative minds behind the series tried to be mindful of what fans wanted, they were also aware of the fine line between fan service and simple pandering.

"We don't overreact, we respect fans of Star Wars, that's really important to us, to Lucasfilm, to the franchise," Iger said. "But we do the best job we can, we think we had a very hard job in bringing this forward... satisfying the traditional fans and touching on themes and characters and places they were familiar with, but introducing the new places, new stories, new characters."

Iger expressed his own satisfaction with the job that his filmmakers had done on the sequels, including J.J. Abrams, who — as the co-writer and director of Rise of Skywalker — had the unenviable task of bringing the nine-film Skywalker Saga to a close in a way that would be true to all of the movies that came before, while still giving fans everything they wanted and telling his own unique story.

"I think over [the sequel trilogy], we've done a really good job of threading that needle, walking that fine line," he said. "We know we're never going to please everybody all the time, and we see that with Disney films, with Marvel films. So I don't mean to suggest that I'm dismissive of it because we respect our fans, but we don't overreact either."

Brace yourself for a shock: many fans and critics disagree. One of the common complaints about Rise of Skywalker has concerned its extreme willingness to indulge in pure fan service at the expense of its story, which can be seen as an ill-advised (if somewhat understandable) course-correction away from the daring narrative choices made by Rian Johnson, who co-wrote and directed previous installment Star Wars: The Last Jedi. 

While that film was one of the best-reviewed in the entire series, it supremely divided fans — many of whom now feel that Abrams has swung too far back in the opposite direction, fielding a final entry that was entirely too safe. Another pervasive gripe: that Rise of Skywalker was illustrative of the fact that the trilogy as a whole lacked a unified vision, which may be why there has recently been talk of future Star Wars movies straying away from the trilogy format.

Lucasfilm President Kathleen Kennedy suggested as much during an interview with the Los Angeles Times over this past weekend. "I think [focusing on single films] gives us a more open-ended view of storytelling and doesn't lock us into this three-act structure," she said. "We're not going to have some finite number and fit it into a box. We're really going to let the story dictate that."

Iger, however, implied that her comments should be taken with a grain of salt. "Oh, I don't know about that," he said. "She and I have said, 'Well, maybe trilogies are too hard, so maybe we'll make one film and then a sequel,' but we don't know."

Of course, it's likely that some observers will take this as yet further evidence that the stewards of Star Wars lack a clear vision for the property — but even the staunchest critics of Iger, Kennedy, and those tasked with bringing fans further adventures set in the galaxy far, far away would have to agree that the House of Mouse hasn't done everything wrong.