The Best True Crime Shows And Movies On Netflix

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

The true crime genre isn't new, but in recent years, the genre has exploded in popularity with podcasts such as Serial and books like I'll Be Gone in the Dark. After all, true crime lets us take a look at what's really going on inside the criminal mind, all from the comfort and safety of our own living rooms. And thanks to Netflix, we've now got more true crime content than we can possibly handle. The streaming service is always releasing tons of films and documentaries about killers, kidnappers, and cult leaders, but there's so much stuff online that finding a new show can be a little overwhelming at times. So if you need some help satisfying your true crime itch and sifting through all those titles, then grab your magnifying glass and prepare to do some investigating as we look at the very best true crime movies and documentaries that Netflix has to offer.

Sister Cathy Cesnik was a nun and teacher at Archbishop Keough High School in Baltimore. Known for her kindness and dependability, Cesnik was loved by her students and everybody close to her. So in 1969, when Cesnik failed to return home one night, it was obvious that something was wrong. Tragically, Cesnik's body was found in early 1970, but for years, the case of the murdered nun was completely cold. That all changed in 1992, when a former Keough student claimed that Father Joseph Maskell, the school's chaplain, had sexually abused her. From there, authorities dove into Father Maskell's backstory, uncovering a history of abuse and a lead in Cesnik's murder.

This twisty tale is documented in The Keepers, a seven-episode series that dives into Cesnik's case and the allegations of sexual abuse that occurred at Archbishop Keough High School. The series explores the notion that Cesnik's murder is directly connected to the claims of abuse, and the show does an excellent job untangling the various testimonies, timelines, and theories associated with Cesik's killing. The Keepers is thoroughly engaging, but it's also deeply emotional and difficult to stomach. It's a story of murder, sexual abuse, and cover-ups. But most importantly, it's about a community of survivors coming together to find justice for Sister Cathy Cesnik and for themselves.

While on an exchange trip in Italy, 20-year-old Amanda Knox found herself the primary suspect of her roommate Meredith Kercher's murder. Though Amanda and her boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, initially were the ones who reported Kercher's death to the police, the cops concluded she and Sollecito were responsible for Meredith's death after the two were interrogated. The couple was swiftly apprehended and ultimately convicted, igniting a worldwide firestorm.

And for anyone looking for information in this crazy, twisty case, Amanda Knox details Kercher's murder, and it highlights the smear campaign that the Italian media executed against Amanda. At every turn, Amanda was painted as a monster, which played a massive role in the guilty verdict. The documentary also details the evidence and police tactics that helped label Knox and her boyfriend as killers. More importantly, the film makes us question if anything about the investigation was actually done the right way.

For those not too familiar with the case, Amanda Knox does an excellent job thoroughly describing Amanda's conviction, the media frenzy that followed, and how all of these factors affected the outcome. For fans of true crime, Amanda Knox is absolutely a must-watch and a major indictment against shoddy police work and tabloid journalism. 

In December 2015, the documentary series Making a Murder was released on Netflix, and almost immediately, the series was a massive hit. It garnered attention from big names like Ricky Gervais, Alec Baldwin, and Mandy Moore on social media. The series even inspired viewers to take action in the form of online petitions, but why did this documentary impact so many people? 

Well, Making a Murderer follows the story of Steven Avery, a man who served 18 years in prison for the attempted murder of Penny Beernsten. With the help of the Innocence Project, Avery was released from prison in 2003 after DNA evidence proved that he was not responsible for the murder. However, two years after his release, Avery was convicted for the murder of a second woman named Teresa Halbach. So is Avery guilty of either crime, or is the man getting railroaded by the system? 

The first season of Making a Murderer is mostly interested in trying to prove Avery's innocence, and the series makes compelling arguments about the handling of his case. The second season focuses more on Avery's lawyer, Kathleen Zellner, as she attempts to prove Avery's innocence while navigating every legal battle imaginable. For anyone wondering why the show is so popular and controversial, now is the time to check it out on Netflix.

Named after the Catholic exercise of self-reflection before a confession, Examination of Conscience is a three-part Spanish series that examines cases of sexual abuse in the Spanish Catholic Church. With interviews from journalists, victims, and abusers alike, this series takes an unflinching look at the abuse that was covered up by the Catholic Church, and it gives survivors an opportunity to share their stories. 

Examination of Conscience dives into decades of allegations against local school officials, priests, and even a friend of Pope Saint John Paul II. In many cases, the survivors' memories have been suppressed for decades, and they've only just begun to confront their difficult pasts. However, the series tackles more than just individual cases of abuse. Many of the survivors talk about how the Church, school officials, and even the government refused to help them and actively turned a blind eye when confronted. 

The series offers a heartbreaking examination of the abuse of power, as well as the cruel, dismissive treatment survivors are often forced to endure. Though the subject matter is painful, Examination of Conscience sheds a light on an often taboo issue, and empowers survivors by giving them a voice. It's definitely a rough watch, but nevertheless, it's a solid series that deserves attention. 

While many view a confession as an admission of guilt, this idea couldn't be further from the truth. A person can be coerced or threatened into admitting to a crime they didn't commit, and by using a person's own words against them, a false confession can serve as the final nail in the coffin that leads to a conviction.

The Confession Tapes is a series that explores cases where people may have been convicted as a result of a false confession. In each of these specific cases, the subjects have confessed to their crimes, but the series questions whether their admittance of guilt was authentic or the result of a miscarriage of justice. Over the course of two seasons, the show features extended sequences of intense interrogations and highly questionable police conduct. As a result, the series can be pretty tough to sit through. Though it may be a challenging watch, The Confession Tapes raises awareness about police misconduct and false confessions, and despite the difficult subject matter, it's absolutely worth sitting through.

The Trials of Gabriel Fernandez is a six-part miniseries about the 2013 murder trial of eight-year-old Gabriel Fernandez. The series showcases the abuse  inflicted upon Gabriel by his mother Pearl and her boyfriend Isauro Aguirre, which ultimately culminated in the child's murder. However, the series also places a focus on the system's failure to protect Gabriel. Over the course of eight months, Gabriel was relentlessly beaten and tortured, and during this time, authorities had been made aware of the abuse. Still, no action was made by the Department of Child and Family Services that may have saved Gabriel, a fact which is addressed at length in the series. 

The series features plenty of expert testimonies in conjunction with courtroom footage and police interviews, all of which come together to create a thoughtful look at how Gabriel was able to fall through the system's cracks. The Trials of Gabriel Fernandez is a heartbreaking watch but offers a compelling perspective on the broader institutional problems in the criminal justice system.

In 1982, Debra Sue Carter was killed after being sexually assaulted inside her home in Ada, Oklahoma. Soon after, two local men, Ron Williamson and Dennis Fritz, were arrested for the crime. Williamson was given a life sentence, while Fritz was sent to death row. Two years later, Denice Haraway was murdered after being abducted from the convenience store where she worked in Ada. Soon afterward, Tommy Ward and Karl Fontenot were arrested for the deed and given life sentences.

As time went on and more people started looking into these two cases, things began to change. After the Innocence Project intervened on behalf of two of the men convicted in 1999, Ron Williamson was released from his life sentence, and his supposed partner in crime Dennis Fritz was freed from death row. After looking at both cases, several similarities started to pop up. Could the still incarcerated Tommy Ward and Karl Fontenot have been innocent this whole time, just like Williamson and Fritz? Partly inspired by the 2006 John Grisham book of the same name, The Innocent Man tackles that very question by looking into Ada police practices at the time, along with closely examining the evidence that put all four men away.

Don't F**k with Cats is a three-part series about the hunt for Luke Magnotta, a man who evoked outrage after he started posting videos of himself killing cats online. The series starts with the early investigation and the Facebook group that was founded in an effort to identify Magnotta, who was posting anonymously. With the help of multiple dedicated individuals, notably Deanna Thompson and John Green, a massive initiative was launched to look for any small clue that could be handed over to the authorities to catch the cat killer. In addition to this team of online sleuths, several law enforcement bodies eventually engaged in the manhunt for Magnotta as well, attempting to track him as he fled across borders.

True to its name, the draw of the documentary is the examination into how different entities attempted to hunt down Luke Magnotta. The series shows investigations stemming from simple tools like using Google Maps to more sophisticated methods such as extracting metadata from photographs or tracking the elusive man down in video surveillance footage. Don't F**k with Cats is a series full of surprising twists and turns, and even those familiar with the case will find themselves sitting on the edge of their seats watching this deadly game of cat and mouse.