Psych Funniest Moments, Ranked

"Psych" is on top of its game when it comes to the holidays. For starters, in "Christmas Joy," pseudo-adults Shawn and Gus are practically helpless when a sobbing child asks for their assistance. Yet the main reason this episode appears on this list stems from Shawn's previous dalliance with Gus' sister, Joy (Faune Chambers Watkins), who's in town for Christmas. Ever the overprotective brother, Gus makes it clear that anyone who approaches his sibling romantically faces his wrath. That includes a just-being-friendly Lassiter, as Gus sternly stares down the detective while he casually asks Shawn what the penalty is for assaulting a police officer. Angry Gus is hard to take seriously, which is what the writers no doubt intended.

The magic revs up one night when Shawn and Joy both have a rendezvous on their mind, only to barely miss each other — and a suspicious Gus — in the Guster's upstairs hallway during a four-door montage reminiscent of a romantic comedy. Naturally, the secret doesn't stay hidden forever, and when it does surface, let's just say it's a good thing the Gusters treat Shawn like family.

Buzz McNab (Sage Brocklebank) is the aw-shucks everyman of "Psych" — he happily does the grunt work at the Santa Barbara Police Department, and every so often, he gets a meatier role. In one Season 3 episode, karma rewards McNab while punishing Juliet and Lassiter, who twice attempt to sideline their subordinate with minutiae only for it to backfire. The first instance is the funniest: Juliet and Lassiter stake out a suspected diamond smuggler only to find a cargo container full of exotic animals.

"I hate marmosets," Lassiter laments. "Apparently, they don't like being shot at," Juliet adds, clearly on the same regretful wavelength. Fast-forward to Season 4, and the audience holds its breath when a bomb knocks McNab flat. Thankfully, he survives, and the writers find a way to make even that near-death experience comical through McNab's post-recovery appearance and concussion-speak. Then in Season 7's "Deez Nups," Juliet, Chief Vick, and Lassiter's fianceé are treated to a stripper who turns out to be — you guessed it — McNab. (His stage name is appropriately dirty, by the way.) More importantly, there's a lot to learn from the way he views life. Plus, you know, there are laughs to be had.

This episode, "Not Even Close ... Encounters," is all about letting its geek flag fly. When a lawyer says his colleague has been abducted by extraterrestrials, Shawn and Gus try to avoid turning into UFO conspiracy theorists. They're successful at first, even inflicting light physical harm when one strays too far from reality. But it becomes harder to stay grounded when they run into childhood friend Dennis Gogolack (Freddie Prinze Jr.), who has transformed from a nerdy stereotype to a "total jock" — or at least, that's what he would have his wife believe. Gogolack's secret bunker full of Renaissance fair costumes, sci-fi memorabilia, and weather-tracking computers is a sight to behold, and watching him own what makes him happy pays off until the end of the episode.

Meanwhile, seeing Shawn and Gus track a suspect while wearing Capt. Adama's helmet from the original "Battlestar Galactica" and Lt. Geordi La Forge from "Star Trek: The Next Generation," respectively, is a riot. Bonus: Henry and Lassiter are hysterical as they debate the merits of a peanut butter prank.

The audience learns through flashbacks that Henry spent much of Shawn's childhood steering him toward law enforcement. Firefighters? Superheroes who "wear their underwear on the outside"? They can't hold a candle to police in the elder Spencer's eyes. Then there are bounty hunters, who draw the disdain of both Henry and Lassiter in "Bounty Hunters!" As for Shawn, he saw Byrd Tatums (Kevin Sorbo) haul in a perp when he was a kid and has had a man-crush ever since. The vest, the hair (smells like "ginger blossoms"), the wristbands — Shawn is all in.

Years later, Shawn gets a chance to prove himself to his "hero" when a murder suspect escapes Juliet's custody and goes on the lam. The catch: The man he and Gus are trying to corral is innocent, and staying ahead of Tatums while keeping the wrongly accused out of the bounty hunter's clutches is no easy feat. Believe it or not, it helps that the fugitive doesn't see the "Psych" duo as a threat. Of course, neither does Tatums, and just about the only thing missing in his laughter-inducing scenes is him lifting Gus' Echo and slamming it to the ground like a wrestler.

Shawn and Gus ultimately get the last laugh on Tatums with some help from Lassiter and Juliet, so everybody wins.

Long before Shawn was using his unconventional methods to solve crimes, Henry was doing it the traditional way, and he was darn good at it, too. But there was one case in the 1970s in which not all the elder Spencer's t's were crossed. In "Disco Didn't Die, It Was Murdered," it's up to Shawn and Gus to make sure a conviction Henry helped secure doesn't unravel on a technicality, and the throwback references are ripe for comedy.

First, Henry steps all over Shawn's toes in hilarious fashion, arriving ahead of the best friends at their first lead and one-upping his son's well-established nickname game. From there, the deeper their investigation goes, the further they sink into the '70s: Clothes straight out of a Bee Gees concert; a car that handles a bit rough, causing Gus' left side to fall asleep and give him a stylish strut; an informant named "Pookie" who thinks Shawn has taken one too many drugs.

If this episode doesn't leave you in tears of joy — and perhaps talking jive — check your pulse.

Sober Lassiter is Shawn's biggest skeptic. Drunk Lassiter, on the other hand, is astounded by Shawn's reasoning, even though he still never buys into the story that he's psychic. Running into an inebriated Lassiter is enough of an ego boost for Shawn that he helps the detective decrypt an "unsolvable" crime when the Santa Barbara Police Department veteran suffers a crippling case of self-doubt. That Shawn and his cohorts help without Lassiter knowing is a spry twist.

In "From the Earth to the Starbucks," the case revolves around a dead astronomer, and Shawn taps into Gus' love for all things celestial by taking a job at the planetarium on the sly. To give Gus a chance to flirt with an intern named Jessica, Shawn volunteers to lead a show where the patrons sit in a dark room and look up at a faux night sky. Appropriately, this episode is ground zero for Gus's go-to pickup line: "You heard about Pluto? That's messed up, right?"

This sets up the best bit of the episode. As Shawn is not even an amateur stargazer, his lack of knowledge has the planetarium visitors tied up in mental knots — and "Psych" viewers in stitches. And when Gus and Jessica come back around after a long chat, she's concerned. "They've been in there 45 minutes," Jessica says. "So?" Gus responds. "It's a four-minute show," she responds. Which explains why the patrons spill out of the auditorium like a gaggle of drunk Lassiters, knocking over garbage cans, each other, and everything else in their path. Pass the Dramamine!

Many shows have cribbed "It's a Wonderful Life," but only "Psych" has Tony Cox guest-starring as Shawn's superego. In "The Polarizing Express," Shawn messes up big time, creating an opening for a criminal to go free. He falls asleep, and while he pieces together clues, he gets a glimpse of what life would be like if he had never come to Santa Barbara. As Shawn's guide on this trippy trek of self-discovery, Cox takes multiple shots at Shawn, who can only stand there and take it despite doing his best to play against little-person stereotypes.

The comedy "CliffsNotes": Henry is glued to the couch and "has become Nick Nolte"; Juliet is an action hero-type cop in Miami, complete with car chases and explosions; and Gus is the doormat in his relationship, but Shawn saves the funny by watching as if it were a '90s sitcom. But the best alternate reality revolves around the changes at the Santa Barbara Police Department. Lassiter is now the chief, wearing full Civil War re-enactment gear and barking out orders for his officers to shoot more bad guys while Chief Vick has undergone a specific type of makeover. "Why does Chief Vick have a German accent?" Shawn asks. "Because you watched 'Austin Powers' last night, and you have a thing for Frau Farbissina — and now so do I," Cox shoots back. 

The episode slows down long enough for the characters to thwart a bombing but otherwise keeps its foot on the gas. Pro tip: Watch for the Grinch causing mayhem.

"Psych" doesn't get any better than this. When a reality show judge (Tim Curry) thinks someone is trying to kill him, Shawn, Gus, and the Santa Barbara Police Department try and smoke out the culprit. From there, Curry steals the show as Nigel St. Nigel, an extreme version of Simon Cowell.

St. Nigel rubs everyone the wrong way — "an equal opportunity bastard" in Gus' words — and the audience wins every time. The police, his fellow judges, the show's host — no one is safe from his barbs. Even Henry gets caught up in the madness when Shawn and Gus use the elder Spencer's place as a safehouse for St. Nigel. Curry's spot-on one-liners are too numerous to mention, though he memorably describes riding in Gus' Toyota Echo as like being "incarcerated in a blueberry" and dislikes the steak Henry serves him because "it's still got the marks where the jockey was hitting it." Now, imagine those lines being delivered in Curry's English accent. You can thank us later.

But wait, there's more. Fellow guest-stars Gina Gershon and Cristián de la Fuente are a revelation as St. Nigel's fellow judges. Notably, Gershon plays the barely lucid Emilina Saffron (think: a fictional version of Paula Abdul), who uses her feminine wiles and bodily functions to drive Lassiter nuts. And even though de la Fuente barely talks throughout the episode because St. Nigel keeps cutting him off, his facial expressions are equally memorable.

All of it adds up to an episode worthy of the TV comedy hall of fame, if such a thing existed. Which it should!