Criminal Minds Top 30 Episodes According To IMDB

During 15 years on the air, "Criminal Minds" racked up 324 episodes — an even more impressive feat when you consider their quality. 

The profiling-based procedural has excelled at offering memorable — and sometimes absolutely nightmarish — cases of the week, ranging from nuanced explorations of realistic (and even sympathetic) criminal behavior to stylized and terrifying thrill rides. It has also created a cast of beloved characters who often went through the wringer, leading to high stakes and even higher emotions. On top of all of that, it rounded up an always-surprising stable of series guest stars, some of whom were compelling enough to lift episodes into greatness all by themselves.

Although "Criminal Minds" supposedly "ended" in early 2020, one year later it was announced that there will be a 10-episode revival airing on Paramount+. If that series does well, who knows how much more time audiences could potentially spend with the BAU?

Looking back on the first 15 seasons, we cross-referenced the show's IMDb rankings and episode scores to come up with the site's consensus favorite "Criminal Minds" episodes. Fans are likely to agree: IMDb users have pretty good taste when it comes to their serial killer dramas. 

"Lucky" had two of the darkest episode punchlines in "Criminal Minds" history, lines no fan will ever forget: "So is Tracy Lambert" and "Hey, Garcia — I've been thinking about doing this all night." The latter line was what made this episode part one of two, so let's talk about that — and its place in a strong subplot about Garcia's insecurities — with the even higher-ranked "Penelope."

But the first line tied into the case of the week, which was especially gruesome and horrifying. The killer was an opportunistic Satanist, one who had seized on the devil as a justification for his own twisted urges, especially cannibalism. The investigation — and the unsub's almost preternatural good luck — forced Morgan to face his own troubled history with religion. The deep ties to characterization made this an especially moving episode.

Maternal instincts were at the heart of this episode. The search for a kidnapped child lead to an ill woman whose delusions had her convinced — at least intermittently — that the boy she'd kidnapped was her own son. It was a sad case, but it had a nicely hopeful resolution that made it stand out.

All the while, Reid was having troubling dreams about discovering a child's body in a basement. The more troubling they got, the more they seemed connected to his actual past — which wasn't what he thought it was. Unearthing his trauma completely threatened to cost him his peace of mind — leading to another great episode, the powerful "Memoriam."

A series of Zodiac copycat killings lifted the lid on a dark and tangled history in "True Genius." 

The episode also touched on a kind of premature midlife crisis child prodigies sometimes go through once they realize how their adult lives have turned out: The unsub felt like he had lost the high-octane intellectual and emotional connection he once shared with his former best friend, and even Reid worried about whether or not he'd measured up to his own high expectations.

"True Genius" was "Zodiac" crossed with Hitchcock's "Rope," making it an awesome standalone case that was one of the series' best. The perfect button on it all was the heartwarming scene at the end, where the team honored Reid's birthday with a bittersweet celebration.

In this heartbreaking, pulse-pounding episode, Prentiss wound up in a fateful standoff with Ian Doyle, a terrorist she'd worked against in her Interpol days. Back then, Doyle knew her as "Lauren Reynolds," the woman of his dreams. Now, he blamed her for his son's death, and was determined to make her pay. But Prentiss had more than a few revelations up her sleeve, and she wasn't about to go down easily.

The real kicker of "Lauren," however, was that the team didn't know the full extent of that. At the end of the episode, they thought Prentiss was dead — even attending her funeral. But, aided by J.J., she had actually gone on the run to ensure that Doyle wouldn't try to get to her by hurting her friends.

"Lauren" was excellent, both as a thriller and a showcase for Prentiss, one of the best "Criminal Minds" characters — and thankfully, not really her final appearance.

The Season 2 premiere continued the "Fisher King" plotline, in which the team was sent on an Arthurian-tinged quest involving an elaborate puzzle. 

Meanwhile, the episode also tackled the biggest part of Season 1's cliffhanger finale: What happened to Elle? In "Part 2," viewers received a far-from-reassuring answer: hovering between life and death, things for Elle could go either way.

A powerful season-opener, "The Fisher King: Part 2" adeptly tied the characters' lives and idiosyncrasies into the plot. The eventual revelation about how it all tied back to Reid's mother — and his guilt over a reluctance to visit her in the hospital — was expertly navigated (and resulted in more Jane Lynch, which is never a bad thing).

One of the show's creepiest cases became one of its most unexpectedly affecting in "The Uncanny Valley." 

A female unsub was abducting women and drugging them to make them into immaculately groomed and costumed living dolls — beyond nightmarish, especially since the women, although paralyzed, were conscious the whole time. Once the team unraveled why the unsub was the way she was, the story only became bleaker, and the resolution began to become more vital.

Ultimately, in "The Uncanny Valley," the creepy trappings mattered less than the portrayal of courage and teamwork and, on the other hand, the sensitive exploration of pain and the corrupt misuse of power. The episode also incorporated a particularly cool investigation tidbit involving a defunct doll company and its write-in competition, and it showed off Jonathan Frakes in a quietly horrific role. This one was strong in themes, storytelling, and performances, earning a well-deserved spot on this list.

Following up on "The Instincts," "Memoriam" dove headfirst into Reid's mysterious dreams about an ominous gap in his childhood memories.

When Reid had nightmares that his estranged father was a murderer, was it only symbolic? Or had he actually been picking up on something? The episode always hung on the precipice of going incredibly dark, as Reid's memories continued to suggest awful secrets about his father and his own life — ratcheting up the tension around the team's concern that this might be one case Reid would be better off avoiding.

The past case had a clever resolution, but the feelings were really the star of the episode. It was awesome to watch the team rally around one of their own, and Reid's muddled feelings and moral dilemma were potent, rendering the highest of stakes. On a lighter note, the episode also gave viewers the birth of J.J.'s son, making for an ending both hopeful and adorable.

The terrorist plot from "Lo-Fi" continued with this suspenseful Season 4 premiere. 

The episode built up with several high-quality twists, keeping viewers guessing about the terrorists' ultimate goal. The cops were hoping that multiple deaths and a high-profile bombing were the end of the statement, but as Rossi was quick to point out — as horrific as that was, it paled in comparison to 9/11 — and with perps likely determined to unleash something bigger, the clock was ticking for them to figure out their plans.

This episode would be strong throughout, with great plotting and tension, but one of the best parts may have been the gut-wrenching scene where Hotch repeatedly begged the emergency first responders to come through the barricade and help the severely wounded Agent Joyner. Knowing that they were under orders not to intervene yet, since everything had led them to expect a second bomb would hit the incoming paramedics, he continued to plead for help anyway. 

When the usually-stoic Hotch broke down, it was a moment "Minds" fans would never forget.

Hostage situations bring out the best in "Criminal Minds," and "Derailed" was an early, highly successful example of that. 

Coming back from an interview in Texas, Elle's train was forced to make an emergency stop. Dr. Bryar — a physicist hospitalized for paranoid schizophrenia — saw both the stop and Elle's FBI status as ominous signs that the "higher authority" he feared were following him. Managing to take the train car hostage, it became a terrifying situation because negotiating him would only play into — and satisfy, thereby increasing — his delusions.

Bryar wasn't truly malicious, he was simply in tremendous mental and emotional pain — and actor Chris Bauer portrayed that skillfully, lending the episode additional pathos. The jumbled cast of civilian train passengers, all wild-cards, added some fun — as did the use of close-up magic to save the day.

Penelope Garcia, one of the show's most beloved characters, began "Penelope" with her life on the line. The episode followed on the heels of "Lucky," where Garcia's date finished with her charming mystery man shooting her in the chest. Now, the team had to try to figure out why a killer became fixated on their technical analyst — and what it might have to do with Garcia's extracurricular efforts to help victims find justice.

In addition to being a lovely Garcia episode, this one also introduced her long-standing boyfriend Kevin Lynch (Nicholas Brendan). It had a bonus focus on the relationship between Morgan and Garcia, as the extreme situation took their usual friendship and playful flirtation even deeper, giving them some incredibly sweet, touching scenes together.

"Conflicted" handled a touchy topic — a split-personality killer — with impressive sensitivity. Here, the damaged, fragile Adam was sometimes subsumed by his protector, the more aggressive Amanda. This was detailed with tremendous empathy, resulting in a poignant, distinctive episode. 

Evoking trans issues in a way that was impressively eye-opening at the time (even if it hasn't really held up with time), the sincerity at the heart of "Conflicted" is unmistakable, and both Adam and Amanda would become sympathetic.

The episode also got a lot of mileage out of the way the multiple personalities here paralleled Reid's experience with Tobias Hankel. "Criminal Minds" has always been at its most compelling when drawing upon such serialized elements, and "Conflicted" lets the characters' past traumas influence their present — so, when Reid cited Tobias as the reason he so badly wanted to rescue Adam from his more dominant alter ego, it was a shorthand the audience understood immediately.

"Criminal Minds" went to Hollywood in this episode, after a string of murders turned out to be the handiwork of a single killer. The perpetrator was a stalker, obsessed with up-and-coming TV actress Lila Archer (Amber Heard), planning deaths to "help" Lila by eliminating her competition and punishing a producer who chose another actress. But as the stalker came to feel under-appreciated, Lila herself became a target.

"Somebody's Watching" came alive with its examination of the sordid, lonely side of even B-list celebrity life. Exploring the thin line between a paparazzo and a stalker, there were some interesting comparisons made. Then there was the flirtation and bittersweet romance between Lila and Reid, both enjoyable and well-handled. There aren't many "Criminal Minds" episodes you could watch on Valentine's Day, but "Somebody's Watching" wouldn't be a bad pick.

There are other actors in this episode besides Matthew Gray Gubler and Aubrey Plaza, but you might not remember them once you're done watching it. 

Most of "Entropy" was an unbelievably dramatic two-person cat-and-mouse game, without them ever leaving a restaurant table. Plaza plays Cat Adams, a contract killer Reid needed to lure out into the open. But she suspected his intentions, and now if Reid didn't make every single play exactly right, she could win.

Gubler and Plaza would prove to have unbelievable chemistry, dark and crackling and full of mutual insight. Both actors know how to expertly dole out breadcrumbs as their characters used the information they gathered about each other to devastating effect. "Entropy" wrapped up one of the show's ongoing arcs, but its immediacy and charismatic hero-villain standoff makes it memorable on its own.

This episode focused on a couple who had spent years periodically abducting children to form a kind of twisted "family," one that lived in their basement and was forced to cooperate with other kidnappings. The latest abduction (which at first appeared to stand alone), prompted J.J. to look into a strange similarity with another kidnapping eight years ago — one where the mother had never given up hoping that her son was alive, continually advocating for the investigation of his case.

"Mosley Lane," like a handful of other memorable "Criminal Minds" episodes, had distinct horror movie overtones, lending it distinctive visuals and a grimy terror. While some of its details could be viewed as extreme, it grounded such episodes in all-too-believable parental grief and terror. As a result, viewers could never stop feeling for them — and never stop being anxious about the fates of their children.

This high-octane, suffocatingly tense episode was the second in a two-parter. The first installment ended with suspect Tobias Hankel abducting Reid — and here, we saw Reid's prolonged ordeal and the team's fight to save him.

Emotions in this episode ran high, making it easy to see how fans got swept up. The situation was so personal and tense: Even if you watched it knowing Reid wouldn't die, you were still seeing him being beaten, forcibly addicted to Dilaudid, psychologically tortured with Russian roulette, and forced to make choices between Henkell's prospective victims. Taken as a whole, it was intense — and that intensity made it all the more rewarding when Reid still managed to figure out how to send coded messages to his team via Henkell's live-streaming.

But when fans talk about what makes this arguably the greatest "Criminal Minds" episode, they can't discount James Van Der Beek's performance. 

Perhaps you didn't see Dawson Leery as a serial killer, but after this, you certainly could. Since he was playing a man whose personality had fractured, you could also see Van Der Beek's character as another victim, one whose plight was heart-wrenching all on its own. Tobias Hankel was essentially his father's tortured, reluctant accomplice — one doing what he could to ease Reid's suffering. It was the cherry on top of a classic episode.