The Further Mis-Adventures Of Cliff Booth Review: David Fincher And Quentin Tarantino Team Up On One Of Their Weakest Movies
- Elizabeth Debicki is great here
- Of course a Tarantino screenplay will have some amusing scenes
- Lacks the heart of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
- Cliff Booth is a Gary Stu
- Questionable cinematography and effects
It's now been seven years since we met the stuntman Cliff Booth (Brad Pitt) in "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood." Since then, Quentin Tarantino has mostly been in the news for two things: being a jerk with bad opinions, and not making his long-promised 10th and supposedly final movie. The former isn't a new phenomenon, but when you don't have new movies to remind you of Tarantino's one-of-a-kind talent, it's more wearying. And about his reasoning for wanting to only direct 10 movies: he used to say it was because directors lose their flair past age 60 (not true for Martin Scorsese or Steven Spielberg or Akira Kurosawa, among others, but go on ...). Now, the 63-year-old Tarantino's rants about how movies died in 2019 (the year he released "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood") make him feel old.
Tarantino wrote a 230-page script for the "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood" sequel "The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth", but not wanting it to be his "10th and final film," he gave it to David Fincher to direct. Slimmed down to a still rather long 2.5 hours, the resulting collaboration is watchable — Tarantino's too good a writer and Fincher's too good a director to make something unwatchable — but thoroughly inessential, maybe even pointless. There's an essential disjoint between the two filmmakers' strengths: Tarantino thrives on fooling around, and his Cliff Booth movies push that far into near-plotless "hangout movie" territory, but Fincher's sense of precision and tension is rarely served by this script and ends up failing the looser vibe the most entertaining version of the material would probably need.
Duller style and less substance than its predecessor
"The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth" is a big stylistic change, and in my opinion a step down, from "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood." Some of this might be attributed to 1977 being a less fun year aesthetically than 1969, but the changing setting doesn't justify why Erik Messerschmidt's cinematography here is just so underlit and desaturated compared to Robert Richardson's in the previous film. There's also the matter of distracting special effects. While David Fincher has always used more CGI than Quentin Tarantino, some of the effects here are below his usual standards, especially when presented in IMAX. One montage of fictional old TV shows, narrated by Tarantino himself, should be a fun bit of world-building, but I kept getting distracted by how fake and digital a lot of the stunts looked (I hesitate to assume AI usage without evidence, but suspicions have been raised).
Everywhere Cliff goes in the new movie, he's greeted with one of two questions: those who don't know him ask if they know him from somewhere, and those who know him ask what Rick Dalton (Leonardo DiCaprio's character from "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood") is up to. The former running gag has a hilarious payoff, but the latter goes nowhere, just repeating the same line about Rick getting fat and moving to Australia. Given the previous film was all about Rick and Cliff's friendship, the way this gets passed over — without even an attempt to find drama in the loneliness of leaving a long-time friend — feels underwhelming.
In Rick's absence, Cliff just isn't a dramatically interesting character. He's so obviously Tarantino's "Gary Stu," to borrow a term from fan fiction discourse — an idealized self-insert character written to be the coolest guy ever that everyone loves. If you rolled your eyes at Cliff Booth beating Bruce Lee in a fight in the last movie, here we learn he also beat Jim Brown in a fight and liberated the Philippines in World War II. His one big edgy character flaw — that he probably (or definitely, in the novelization) killed his wife — is extra gross to think about in light of the domestic abuse allegations against Pitt. Here, at least, the main plot involves him stopping someone else from committing that sort of violence.
What little plot there is feels disjointed
So yeah, there is something of a plot here: Cliff is hired by talent agent Karen Crosby (Elizabeth Debicki) to work with Charlie Peters (Scott Caan), an actor known for doing all his own stunts. Charlie is married to Cliff's ex Toni (Carla Gugino), while Cliff wants Karen to dominate him; the relationship comedy with the four characters together is where the movie is most entertaining. Eventually, Charlie reveals the reason he wanted Cliff's services: while visiting the Philippines, he hired two gangsters, Eddie and Fernando Verdusco (Matt Groove and JB Tadena), to kill his wife, and now, regretting that decision, he wants Cliff to stop them.
The Verdusco brothers appear sporadically throughout the movie, but when they do, the tone shifts entirely. They're scary characters, and the violence they commit is startlingly nasty even by Quentin Tarantino's standards (I can't recall any other Tarantino movies where children get graphically shot in the head). David Fincher can direct these intense scenes effectively, but isn't great at making them flow with all the sillier Tarantinian digressions that make up 90% of the runtime. The action climax where Cliff takes the gangsters out has its exciting moments, but it's not as awesome as it could be, dragged down by the dark cinematography and a rushed conclusion.
Debicki's performance is easily the best thing this movie has going for it. She's funny, sexy, and has the most interestingly written character to work with. Her character used to be a film critic, and I wonder if some elements of her role came from Tarantino's unmade "final film" proposal titled "The Movie Critic." In one memorable sequence, she argues that Hollywood movies aren't art, rejecting even "The Godfather" as merely having "artistic qualities" atop the narrative equivalent of a fast food burger.
I'm sure Tarantino and Fincher disagree with Karen's sentiment, but it does seem indicative of their approach with this film: they're not making art, they're making a burger. The problem is it's just not that tasty a burger, maybe their most mediocre yet.
"The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth" opens in theaters November 25. It will stream on Netflix starting December 23.