Game Romances Fans Absolutely Despised

Some bachelors in Stardew Valley are more appealing than others, but many fans can unite in their hatred of Shane. Shane doesn't shine like some of the other eligible folks in town. Take Abigail, a villager who has a more interesting storyline than Shane, considering that the local wizard may be her father and she regularly eats quartz for fun. Yet Shane remains a speedrunner favorite, mainly because of his consistent schedule and easily obtained likes.

No matter how easily speedrunners can win over Shane's heart, his grumpy attitude remains a major turn off for many Stardew Valley fans. In one Reddit thread, user StarDew_Factory makes an argument for Shane, analyzing his journey from depressed alcoholic to loving husband and father. The post aptly points out that changing one's life takes a considerable amount of time, and that fans should give Shane some grace. One reply to the thread notes that Shane's behavior after marriage is the real problem. After players marry Shane, seemingly helping him ditch booze and turn his life around, his dialogue options revert to talk of alcohol and depression, like nothing ever happened.

There's nothing a Stardew Valley player hates more than having their hard work erased, and romancing Shane makes that an inevitability.

Sonic and his human princess might share an awkward kiss in 2006's Sonic the Hedgehog, but fans think their entire relationship is uncomfortable. MojoPlays calls the pair the worst video game couple of all time because of their lack of chemistry on screen.

On a message board discussion of the hedgehog/human romance, one fan posits that perhaps the doting Princess Elise acts as a stand in for the Sonic fanbase itself. While the original poster waxes poetic about the dev team's intentions with the romance, another fan responds, "They weren't thinking."

Of course, fans might have predicted the blue hedgehog's predilection for human women. At one point in early developement, the original Sonic the Hedgehog game included Sonic's human girlfriend, Madonna, before her existence got scrapped from the franchise entirely. Princess Elise looks nothing like the busty, blonde woman Sonic could have dated, but they do have their humanity in common.

Critics despised Sonic and Princess Elise's romance so much that Kotaku has an entire article detailing why the relationship doesn't work, and why it's an affront to fans everywhere.

Conceptually, there's nothing off about Shephard and Liara's romance in Mass Effect, but fans have noted that their arc stands out as one of the most poorly written in the series.

No matter what players want, Liara is an important part of the game. A fan blog about Liara argues that she's a creator's pet, a character that, through no intention of the writer, becomes such a favorite that they move to the forefront of plot and interest in the game. The post points out other characters that have more interesting stories or dialogue, but notes that Liara always finds her way back to the center of things, even if Shephard does not choose to romance her. Basically, Liara's significance to the overarching story of Mass Effect makes her a polarizing figure in the fan community.

Another complicating aspect of Liara's relationship with Shephard relates to gender. Asari, the race Liara belongs to, do not present as one gender or another, and some even choose to use gender neutral pronouns, as revealed in Andromeda. This detail allows male and female versions of Shephard to pursue a relationship with Liara, further showing her prominence within the game and story.

Ultimately, it doesn't really matter what players decide about romancing Liara, she's going to catch feelings either way.

Assassin's Creed: Unity shipped before all the kinks were worked out, and fans took notice, but the most disappointing aspect to some players lies in character design, not technology. Some players consider AC: Unity one of the worst games in the series, specifically because of its poor character development. 

One fan discussion of the game asserts, "Arno is the most pathetic main character of the series, dude is just obsessed with Elise and everything he does depends on her (no agency whatsoever, doesn't give a **** about the Assassins or the Revolution)." Though some fans argue that liking or disliking Arno and Elise's relationship is a simple matter of taste, the general fan community seems to strongly dislike AC: Unity and the romance that blossoms within it.

Worse than disliking the game and its plot, some fans don't buy the story of AC: Unity. One fan describes their relief when Elise died, noting that "It felt like Arno was being walked all over and manipulated, giving the whole game a really skeevy vibe." Love it or hate it, there's no changing the big romance of Assassin's Creed: Unity now. The only thing to do is move on to another assassin, in another time, and try to forget Arno and Elise ever happened.

Heavy Rain had several issues that look worse years later, but Ethan and Madison's romance was bad ten years ago, and bad now. They're an odd pair from the start. Ethan is a grieving father that reaches out to Madison to drum up interest in his case after his son disappears. Madison agrees to help Ethan because of her journalistic interest in his case, but the two can quickly, and inexplicably, fall in love and engage in one of the most awkward sex scenes of all time.

In a thorough review of Heavy Rain, Ken Cummings analyzes why Madison and Ethan's relationship proves tiring. He argues that Ethan's willingness to sleep with Madison seems at odds with his deep concern for his son, which he claims is the most pressing matter in his life. Similarly, writer Cameron Kunzelman calls Madison's frequent state of undress "just plain gross," because it feels exploitative and inappropriate to the overall tone of the game.

Either way, fans felt weirded out by the pairing, with one player commenting, "I thought that they would kiss, but then it just snowballs into this sex scene and I wanted it to stop."

As a long running series, Final Fantasy has many great romances scattered throughout its long history. Of course, they can't all be winners. Fans felt that Snow and Serah of Final Fantasy 13 felt boring and poorly written.

One player pointed out that Serah and Snow act like they don't know each other for much of the game, ignoring each other's presence or downright insulting each other in cutscenes. Some fans considered their already strange relationship even weaker in Final Fantasy 13-2. The sequel to Final Fantasy 13 provides players with a multitude of choices, but ditching Snow and Serah isn't one of them.

Other critics have noted that Snow and Serah's plotline seems more suited to a soap opera than a video game, and that needless drama only delays more important game functions like, you know, battling monsters and such. Unfortunately, Serah doesn't stand out in a crowd of Final Fantasy characters, and her relationship to Snow feels unnecessary to the game as a whole.

The Persona series has always included lots of romance options for players, and has done a relatively good job about correcting any cultural missteps it makes along the way. However, fans found it difficult to excuse one of Joker's Confidant relationships. Joker has the option of deepening his relationship with Sadayo Kawakami, his teacher at Shujin Academy who works as a maid in her off time. The ethics of a student dating his teacher are murky at best and definitely illegal in most circles.

Some fans simply found Kawakami "annoying," noting that her character doesn't provide anything particularly useful or special to players. Others found it odd that Kawakami appears alongside other romance options in the game during certain cutscenes, as if there's nothing different about her. Even though she teaches most of the other girls Joker can choose to date, they say nothing about her presence or her relationship with Joker.

Fans of the relationship argue that Kawakami and Joker's story arc is fictional and harmless, a way for players to project their own desires into the game, but the choice to date your teacher remains controversial. Ultimately, no fan can deny that Kawakami and Joker's relationship has an unequal balance of power, which throws any hint of ethics out the window.