Zelda Clones That Caused A Serious Uproar

The great playwright Oscar Wilde said, "Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery that mediocrity can pay to greatness." And for a franchise as legendary as The Legend of Zelda, imitation is to be expected. After all, if you're going to look for inspiration for your game, there may not be a better formula to borrow than the one that built the Zelda franchise into the gaming titan it is today. Combining vast, open-world exploration and mysterious dungeons with exciting combat and challenging puzzles, the Zelda blueprint is time-tested, and provides a path forward for developers who wish to make a name for themselves.

Indeed, the Zelda formula clearly works, which is why there exists an entire subgenre of clones clamoring for attention. Since the '80s, developers have glommed on to the Zelda formula in an attempt to appeal to that franchise's fan base. Sometimes, the clone actually holds its own. Other times, the imitation fails to impress. Some clones may appear to be complete knock-offs, while others do manage to bring genuine innovation to the table.

Whether you love them or hate them, these are some Zelda clones that caused a serious uproar.

Of the Zelda clones, few have received as much backlash as Genshin Impact. Here is a game that got fans so riled up, one even went so far as to destroy his PS4 in protest. Other less-extreme protesters held up their Switch consoles and middle fingers during a gameplay demo at the ChinaJoy expo. 

Much of this outrage was sparked by Sony's support of Genshin Impact after footage revealed it to bear a striking resemblance to Breath of the Wild. But more than just a lookalike, this game appeared to feature very similar mechanics and settings.

Reactions were clearly heated and volatile, though possibly unjustified. While there's no denying that certain elements were lifted straight out of Breath of the Wild, there are some key differences. IGN's Daniel Robson described Genshin Impact as a "Zelda clone that's not really a Zelda clone." For one, it tells an original story. There are around 30 characters you can choose from, in contrast to Zelda's sole playable protagonist. The game offers a fairly in-depth RPG system unlike Breath of the Wild. To top it all off, Genshin Impact's art style is a celebration of manga and anime. As CCN's Thomas Bardwell suggested, considering Breath of the Wild's success, a knock-off may not be a bad thing.

At what point does an homage cross into infringement territory? This is exactly what Mark Methenitis of Engadget explored in response to the outcry of copyright infringement from gamers over 3D Dot Game Heroes. It's easy to see how such an issue could arise after hearing the music and looking at the environments, enemies, and gameplay. The overall premise is an ode to gaming of that era, so such comparisons could be a sign of a job well done.

Ultimately, Methenitis concluded that he personally saw no infringement on the part of 3D Dot Game Heroes. But this hasn't prevented others from viewing it as such.

In an article on Kotaku, Mike Fahey set out to see if 3D Dot Game Heroes could be "labeled a gimmicky Zelda clone." With so many fans claiming it was a PS3-exclusive Zelda knock-off, Fahey yielded to the notion that it was "derivative . . . but it's derivative done well." He did note that the gameplay somewhat suffered as a result of the game's attempt to emulate a bygone era of gaming. In the end, he left it up to audiences to decide whether it's just a tribute or a shameless copy.

Remember the Master System? Many are familiar with this Sega Genesis predecessor, though it was greatly overshadowed by the giant that was the Nintendo Entertainment System. The Master System was the underdog in a battle that preceded the great console wars of the '90s. As such, Sega was bound to unleash its own version of The Legend of Zelda in a shameless attempt to compete against Nintendo.

That competition came in the form of Golvellius: The Valley of Doom, which released on the Master System in 1988.

More than just a knock-off, Golvellius took formulas from the two existing Zelda titles at the time and merged them into one game. The result was a mix of overhead and side-scrolling action. Like the first Zelda, the overhead sections had combat. But where Zelda 2 forced players to find their way through diverging paths in its side-scrolling dungeons, Golvellius progressed in a more traditional, linear fashion.

Golvellius never made much of a splash. As such, it managed to sneak by without offending too many Zelda diehards. In fact, USgamer's Jeremy Parish actually praised the game's atmosphere, graphics, and music, calling it "an ambitious and honestly sometimes incredible game."

Have you ever wondered what The Legend of Zelda would have been like if it took place in the Wild West? If so, Ganpuru: Gunman's Proof might offer some insight. Destructoid's Allistair Pinsof called it a "shameless A Link to the Past carbon copy," though it does have some notable qualities you won't find in the Zelda franchise.

Ganpuru: Gunman's Proof is not just a Zelda-like in a Wild West setting; it also involves aliens! In fact, you control the body of a farmhand who is possessed by one of these recently marooned extraterrestrials, which makes for some interesting NPC interactions. That seems to be where the fun ends, though. Like any true Zelda clone, Gunman's Proof has you exploring dungeons and uncovering key items vital to your progression. Unfortunately, with linear travel, an absence of puzzles, and simple boss battles, the dungeons are not well executed.

While the game falls short in a lot of ways (and appears to rip off Zelda to the point of lifting assets straight out of A Link to the Past), it does possess style. In his review, Pinsof praised the game's look and the imaginative world it occupies.

Evoland is an interesting case in the world of Zelda clones in that it's hard to write it off as another knock-off. Rather, it's more a celebration of video game history. Though it does begin with gameplay that is directly inspired by Zelda, it gradually evolves into several different types of games, borrowing from Final Fantasy and Diablo, as well.

Breaking the fourth wall, Evoland is a light-hearted exploration of the evolution of gaming where the world goes from black and white to color, to 3D, and beyond. Features that most gamers take for granted, like saving and purchasing items, must be unlocked. The mechanics change too, beginning with classic swordplay, then introducing a turn-based system, followed by Diablo-style combat.

In its short duration, Evoland fails to deliver a deep gameplay experience for any genre it emulates. David Klemke of The Refined Geek criticized this lack of depth but gave it credit for its overall presentation.

As far as Zelda clones go, this one gets a pass for its unique approach in presenting gamers with an interactive video game timeline. It may not be the most fun you'll have, but it certainly is clever.

Sometimes a Zelda clone hides in plain sight, complete with the "Nintendo Seal of Quality." In this case, the Nintendo 64 once had Shadow Man sitting in the same section as Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask. Based on a comic book series, Shadow Man puts the player in an open-world environment full of atmosphere and puzzle-solving beats, all of which quickly bring contemporary Zelda titles to mind.

Throughout the game, the titular hero traverses the regular world and the world of the dead. His abilities change depending on which side of mortality he occupies. Much like Ocarina of Time, your exploration is mostly limitless, with certain items unlocking areas that are otherwise restricted.

Even some key control schemes were stolen from Zelda. According to Matt Casamassina's review on IGN, the developers integrated a strafing and targeting button in response to the success of such a function in the 3D Zelda games. Though Casamassina ultimately gave Shadow Man a very high score of 9.1, he noted that the borrowed targeting system doesn't quite measure up to its Zelda counterpart. Shadow Man may be a good game, but it boldly ripped off Zelda on its own turf.

In the '90s, many families were either Sega households or Nintendo households. And of course, those Sega kids hungry for a game like Zelda had several options to satisfy the itch. One of those Zelda clones was Beyond Oasis, which happens to have a strong fan base.

Ron Duwell, a self-proclaimed "Nintendo kid," wrote about his experience with the game, where he credited its cult following to nostalgia. He asserted that there's no comparing Beyond Oasis to A Link to the Past, which he claimed is far superior. While the game has its obvious Zelda tropes, it differs in a distinctly Sega way, according to Duwell, with faster-paced arcade combat and a more restricted means of progression.

Mike Diver of Vice, who grew up in a Sega house and played Beyond Oasis as a kid, shared Duwell's opinion. The game has a fair amount of problems, which Diver wasn't shy to point out. But despite its flaws, he did still enjoy Beyond Oasis, and went so far as to call it "arguably, Sega's greatest 16-bit RPG."

If there's one takeaway from all of this, it's that Beyond Oasis is a solid Zelda clone, though its superiority may be slightly embellished by its fans.