Most Insane Game Show Contestant Fails

While the phrase "game show" has two fun words right there in the name, actually appearing on a televised contest in pursuit of cash jackpots, fabulous prizes, and brief and minor fame isn't as entertaining for the contestants as it is for the people watching at home. Game show contestants have to overcome a lot to emerge from the experience unscathed.

No matter the program, be it "Wheel of Fortune," "Family Feud," "Who Wants to be a Millionaire," "Jeopardy!," or some other entry, there's potentially life-changing money at stake, tremendous pressure to win, and just the generally stressful and strange idea of being on television for probably the first and only time. It's tough for a contestant to have a clear head and maintain focus with all those issues up in the air, not to mention the distractions of an applauding audience, ingratiating host, other competitors standing by, and hot studio lights. Frankly, it's surprising that game show contestants don't mess up more often.

Sure, everyone makes mistakes, but these people did it on television in front of millions of people, their low moments preserved forever on the internet. Here are some of the greatest all-time game show fails.

The game show fates seemed to be pulling for uniformed military member Casey during her 2007 appearance on "Wheel of Fortune." During a successful run of spins, she buys a vowel, "I," and there are two, and host Pat Sajak reveals that only consonants remain. The boisterous Casey spins again and hits the rare and difficult-to-nail "$10,000" piece, which is flanked by two "Bankrupt" slices. Casey guesses a "G," and she'll get a nice 10-grand bonus should she finish the puzzle. That solution is imminent, as the board displays the name of a "Place" — "E_CLUSI_E NIGHTCLUB."

Viewers at home were likely shouting "Exclusive Nightclub" at their screens at this point, but Casey obviously didn't hear them. She didn't know the solution, and spun once more, skirting over a "Bankrupt" fate once more and landing on the $900 spot. Casey then guessed for a K. There's no "K" in "Exclusive Nightclub" — unless you grossly mispronounce it. Her turn over, control of the game went to contestant Ben, who easily and quickly turned in a correct solution.

Somehow, some intrepid TV minds made an exciting, compelling game show out of people pointing at briefcases and then waiting as somebody else opened those briefcases one by one. That's the premise behind "Deal or No Deal," a massive hit for NBC in the 2000s before a long run in syndication. The show's charm lies in its presentation. Each briefcase corresponds to a dollar amount, with one containing the promise of $1 million. Each of the cases is held aloft and opened by a glamorous model.

In seeking to mix up the formula in a May 2006 episode, producers had contestant Lauren Potter's sister surreptitiously appear onstage as one of the briefcase models. The contestant apparently had nothing but potential riches on their mind, because she didn't recognize their own sister until host Howie Mandel pointed her out after offering several clues. The contestant's mother, watching from the sidelines, didn't spot her daughter as the briefcase model either.

Every round of "Family Feud" begins with a face-off at host Steve Harvey's podium. A representative from each team of relatives steps up and has to name the most popular answer given in a recent survey of 100 random people. Doing so wins control of the game, or the right to pass or play, for the contestant's team. Time is of the essence to buzz in first, but it's also important to ascertain all the necessary information before answering.

In a face-off in a 2011 "Family Feud" episode, a contestant named Holly probably thought she had the perfect answer and that she was ready in a timely fashion, too. "Name something a woman does for her baby that she —" host Steve Harvey read. "Changes his diapers," Holly calmly stated after buzzing in. The big "X" chyron and buzzing sound effect let the audience and Holly know that this was not one of the top five answers in the survey. Without a word, Harvey squared in on Holly — and finished reading the question she'd interrupted.  "Name something a woman does for her baby ... that she also does for her hubby," he said. Holly laughed it off, but it's clear she was also more than a little embarrassed.

Kellie Pickler's "Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?" appearance in 2007 is legendary. Competing for prize money she planned to donate to the Red Cross and the AARP, Pickler demonstrated the novel if meandering way she makes an educated guess. "Because I have my ears pierced" led her to correctly ascertain that Franklin Pierce was indeed a U.S. president. But the pinnacle of Pickler's performance came after she was asked to identify the European nation whose capital city is Budapest. Her verbalized thoughts and answers ranged from "I thought Europe was a country," to "I never even heard of that," to "I know they speak French there," to "Is France even a country?"

Host Jeff Foxworthy eventually stepped in to guide her to embrace one of the game's built-in lifelines and "cheat" off of her fifth-grader partner, who correctly answered Hungary. Foxworthy and Pickler then proceeded to repeatedly pronounce it "Hungry," as the 10-year-olds on stage looked at each other in amazement.

In its CBS daytime iteration running since the early 1970s, "The Price Is Right" is split into halves, with the ultimate winner from both squaring off in the final guess-the-price game, the lavish "Showcase Showdown." Presented with an array of luxurious appliances, trips, vehicles, and more, the contestant who gets closer to the total, tough-to-calculate retail price of all that stuff wins everything in their prize selection. The trick is that they can't overestimate the price — that's an instant loss and disqualification.

In a "Price Is Right" installment that aired in March 2021, a contestant named Jenna was tasked with pricing a collection of prizes that included a new car, a home theater, and a video camera. Jennifer's guess: $23,294. Her opponent, Robert, overbid by $6,083, so all Jennifer had to do to win big was just be under the "actual retail price." In the moment of truth, host Drew Carey revealed the real cost: $23,291. Jennifer had gone over and thus lost the game — by a margin of just $3.

Tennessee Williams is one of the best-known and most widely read and performed American playwrights. His character studies of broken people living in evocative Southern settings include "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof," and "A Streetcar Named Desire," whose 1951 film adaptation won four Academy Awards and spawned the indelible image of a young Marlon Brando shouting "Stella!" Not too many plays are part of the collective consciousness, but "A Streetcar Named Desire" is — although not entirely, as suggested by an episode of "Wheel of Fortune" that aired in March 2017.

With the puzzle revealed as "A STREETCAR NA_ED DESIRE" and so almost solved, contestant Kevin just doesn't know it or wants more money, so he opts to spin again. Landing on the $600 space, he guesses "K" — theorizing that the "Title" to guess is "A Streetcar Naked Desire," which isn't the title of anything. Losing his turn, control of the board moves to contestant Lisa, who quickly spins and correctly asks for an "M."

For years, "Saturday Night Live" ran a series of sketches parodying "Celebrity Jeopardy!" Playing off the exaggerated notion that famous actors and rock stars aren't exactly the brightest people, the sketches followed a formula of host Alex Trebek (Will Ferrell) growing ever more exasperated by the celebrity contestants' monumentally dumb answers born out of their disconnection from reality and lack of common knowledge.

In April 1998, the real "Jeopardy!" aired a few nights of "Celebrity Invitational" games, and the first pitted "MTV Sports" star Dan Cortese against TV legends Jason Alexander of "Seinfeld" and Carol Burnett. This actual "Celebrity Jeopardy!" imitated the "SNL" version quite realistically. Trebek read this prompt: "One common shape of the stomach is like this tenth letter of the alphabet." To score the points, all any of those contestants had to do was name a letter. After a few seconds of complete and telling silence, Cortese buzzed in first, guessing "L." Alexander and Burnett, meanwhile, recited the alphabet and counted on their fingers while giggling. Finally venturing a guess, Alexander suggested "K." Wrong again. Finally, an exuberant Burnett realized that the 10th letter of the alphabet is "J."

As much as it can be a dazzling display of knowledge executed swiftly, "Jeopardy!" involves tons of luck and intuition. Not even the most genius "Jeopardy!" contestant knows everything about everything — they've each got their specialties and favorite categories. In an episode airing in January 2016, all three "Jeopardy!" competitors must have felt very confident when the "Final Jeopardy" category popped up. It was "State Capitals." The statement, as read by Alex Trebek, teased: "A 1957 event led to the creation of a national historic site in this city, signed into law by a president whose library is now there too."

When asked to place their individual wagers, contestants Mike and Claudia were tied for first place, with $13,800 each, with Randi trailing at $6,000. But then, they all wrote their answers down and Trebek revealed how much they each gained, or lost, as the case may be. That's because Mike, Claudia, and Randi each bet their entire amounts on "Final Jeopardy." And they all answered the question incorrectly. (It wasn't Austin or Atlanta, but Little Rock, Arkansas.) The game ended in a three-way tie, technically, as all these "Jeopardy!" contestants finished with $0.

In December 2010, engaged couple Gabe Okoye and Brittany Mayti appeared on the Fox game show "Million Dollar Money Drop." Okoye and Mayti answered so many trivia questions correctly — and astutely bet the proper and most lucrative portions of their winnings, as that was part of the game — that they'd amassed $880,000. Then one question threw them off. Host Kevin Pollak asked, "Which of these was sold in stores first?" The choices were the Macintosh computer, the Sony Walkman, and Post-It Notes. Okoye was pretty sure the Post-It came first, while Mayti thought the Walkman was the right answer. Okoye ultimately persuaded his fiancée, and they bet $800,000 of their fortune on Post-Its and the remaining $80,000 on the Walkman. Mayti had seemingly been right all along — Walkman was deemed the right answer. The team instantly saw $800,000 slip away and then were so rattled they lost the rest of the money in the remainder of the game.

But then came the internet chatter — what if "Million Dollar Money Drop" was the party who got it wrong? It turns out Post-Its were available before the Walkman, having been invented in 1977 and sold in some stores before national rollout began in 1980. Executive producer Jeff Apploff released a statement saying, "In this case, our research team spoke directly with 3M, and they confirmed that although they had given out free samples in test markets in 1977 and 1978, it wasn't until 1980 that Post-Its were sold in stores. Million Dollar Money Drop stands behind the answer that was revealed on the show." The series was canceled after its first season.

One massive error on a game show is enough to enter a person into the hall of fame for televised mistakes. To make two or more big goofs is almost unthinkable. But Karen Morris made "Jeopardy!" history on an episode that aired in March 2023 by not only overly waging on a late-game "Daily Double," but then providing back-to-back incorrect answers.

Morris led her competitors by a margin of more than $14,000 and then bet a whopping $10,000 on the "Daily Double." Concerning painter Hans Holbein the Younger, Morris didn't know the answer, and there wasn't enough time left in the game to get her score boosted, so she entered "Final Jeopardy," and the category "American Novelists," with $11,400. Still in first place, she didn't make a safe bet to stay competitive with her opponents in case she got the response wrong — which she did. The proper reply, offered by contestants Melissa and Zach, was "Catch-22" author Joseph Heller; Morris wrote down "Hunter S. Thompson." She lost her $6,001 miscalculated bet and finished in third place. Because she had a sizable lead, had she not wagered a penny on either difficult prompt, Morris might have kept her $21,800 and made it out unscathed in first place.